I love this mascara, have been using it for years and will use is for as long as it exists. It’s great for its price and the best one I’ve found in this price range. It’s the perfect black. It applies enough in the first coat but I always like to do an extra coat or two - depends on your style. I’d recommend it if you’re looking for something affordable that gives decent results. If you apply correctly, your lashes shouldn’t clump either!